Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Prime Video (Sony Pictures Television) or the show's producers · how we work

Fan theoryUpdated Nov 18, 2026 · 6 sources

Temp V vs. Compound V: Fan Theories on DNA, Aging, and What-If Scenarios

Community discussions on r/TheBoys continue to analyze the exact mechanics of Temp V and Compound V. Fans are debating whether powers are tied to genetics or individual vials, comparing the different versions of powered Billy Butcher, and proposing alternate scenarios involving Hughie, Homelander, and the Godolkin Supe-Virus.

Do DNA and Vials Dictate Temp V Powers?

A recent fan theory thread on r/TheBoys raises questions about how Temp V and Compound V assign abilities to users. Fans noted that Billy Butcher consistently manifests powers similar to Homelander every time he takes Temp V, while Hughie always receives the ability to teleport.

The community is split on the underlying mechanics, as an official explanation is not known yet. One theory suggests that Temp V powers are predetermined by an individual's DNA and genetics, while an opposing view wonders if grabbing different vials would result in entirely different powers.

Meanwhile, fans are also comparing Temp V Butcher with Compound V Butcher. While posts on r/TheBoys note that Compound V Butcher is stronger than the Temp V version, viewers remain undecided on which version of the character they prefer overall.

Homelander's Reaction at Herogasm and Supe Aging

Viewers on r/TheBoys are also revisiting specific moments involving Temp V durability, such as the confrontation at Herogasm. One fan discussion questions why Homelander was not surprised when his laser vision only knocked Butcher unconscious instead of vaporizing him, despite not knowing yet that Butcher had taken Temp V.

Another community debate focuses on the long-term effects of Compound V and what would happen if Homelander grew old. Fans are theorizing about whether an elderly Homelander would retain his full strength or become super weak like the lower-tier Supes beneath him.

Fan What-Ifs: The Godolkin Virus and Hughie's Powers

Beyond the established canon, r/TheBoys users are pitching alternate timelines for the main characters. One hypothetical scenario asks what would have happened if the Godolkin Supe-Virus had already been completed in Season 3, allowing Butcher to use the virus to hunt down Homelander and the Supes instead of relying on Temp V.

A separate fan thread explores a power-swap scenario. Building on earlier posts asking what would happen if Butcher had Homelander's powers, readers are now debating what Hughie would do if he were the one granted Homelander's exact skillset.

Two sides of the debate

Genetics, Permanent Strength, and Temp V

  • Temp V abilities appear tied to a person's genetics and DNA, which explains why Butcher always gets powers similar to Homelander and Hughie always teleports.
  • Compound V Butcher is clearly stronger than his Temp V counterpart, making the permanent Compound V version a top contender for fan favorite.
  • Even if Homelander grew old, his unique level of power might allow him to remain just as strong rather than weakening.

Vial Variety, Aging Limits, and Alternate Paths

  • Temp V powers might actually depend on the specific batch, meaning Butcher and Hughie could have received different powers if they had grabbed different vials.
  • Despite Compound V Butcher being stronger, many fans go back and forth and still favor the Temp V version of Butcher.
  • If Homelander grew old, he could lose his edge and become super weak just like the Supes below him.
  • If a completed Godolkin Supe-Virus had been available in Season 3, Butcher could have used it to hunt Supes rather than taking Temp V at all.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: How do you think Temp V determines a user's powers?

Vote to see what other fans think.

If Hughie had received Homelander's exact powers instead of teleportation, how do you think it would have changed his actions, and would Butcher have skipped Temp V entirely if the Godolkin virus was ready in Season 3?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from The Boys S5