Unofficial fan site · not affiliated with Prime Video (Sony Pictures Television) or the show's producers · how we work

Fan theoryUpdated Nov 18, 2026 · 6 sources

A-Train's Redemption Arc: From The Seven to One of The Boys

Reddit discussions on r/TheBoys highlight A-Train's journey from a member of The Seven to officially being considered one of the good guys. Fans are debating the key moments of his redemption, including his standards against Vought, his handling of Blue Hawk, and reclaiming his identity as Reggie.

From The Seven to The Boys

Following the finale, fans on r/TheBoys noticed a detail during a Deadline interview: actor Jessie T. Usher sat with the cast of The Boys rather than the Seven. Posters noted this mirrors the Season 5 poster and highlights how A-Train's redemption arc ended with him officially considered one of the good guys, though some wished he had stuck around a little bit longer.

Another major talking point on Reddit is how A-Train reclaimed his identity as Reggie to become a real hero without wearing a superhero costume. Discussing a key scene, one fan pointed to comments from Antony Starr in an interview stating that A-Train won right there, proving that the person without the suit was the actual hero between the two of them.

Early Signs of Standards and Breaking from Vought

Community discussions also look back at A-Train's history inside Vought. Fans pointed out that Homelander switched up his attitude toward A-Train every season—hugging him and calling him family as a partial warning in Season 1, kicking him out of the Seven while saying it was not personal in Season 2, and turning on him again in Season 3.

Even before his full redemption when he was still viewed as a bad person, Reddit users noted that A-Train had standards. He consistently made it clear he was anti-Nazi and betrayed Vought right before they started using concentration camps.

Fans also still debate how A-Train handled Blue Hawk. While his brother Nathan criticized the move, some fans argue A-Train made the right call because Vought would have simply paid Nathan off and covered up what Blue Hawk did.

Two sides of the debate

A-Train Became a True Hero

  • He shed the superhero costume, reclaimed his real identity as Reggie, and won the moral victory as a real hero.
  • Both the Season 5 poster and Jessie T. Usher sitting with The Boys cast in a post-finale Deadline interview show he ended as one of the good guys.
  • He took real action against Blue Hawk when Vought would have just paid Nathan off and covered it up.

A Flawed Figure Pushed Out by Vought

  • Even fans praising his anti-Nazi stance and betrayal of Vought acknowledge he was a bad person before his redemption.
  • His brother Nathan disapproved of how A-Train handled the Blue Hawk situation.
  • His split from the Seven followed seasons of Homelander switching up on him and kicking him off the team.

Your turn

How does this make you feel?

Poll: What was the most defining part of A-Train's redemption arc?

Vote to see what other fans think.

Do you think A-Train fully earned his place among The Boys by the end of his arc, or did his past actions as part of The Seven weigh too heavily?

Your take

  1. Loading opinions…

Sources

We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:

More from The Boys S5

Fan theoryTemp V vs. Compound V: Fan Theories on DNA, Aging, and What-If ScenariosCommunity discussions on r/TheBoys continue to analyze the exact mechanics of Temp V and Compound V. Fans are debating whether powers are tied to genetics or individual vials, comparing the different versions of powered Billy Butcher, and proposing alternate scenarios involving Hughie, Homelander, and the Godolkin Supe-Virus.Fan theoryBilly Butcher's Tragic Finale Ending and Moral LegacyCommunity discussions on r/TheBoys are dissecting Billy Butcher's season finale fate and overall moral standing. While fans point to the sadness of his final moments with Ryan and Hughie, others debate whether the writing condemns his reprehensible actions or accidentally glorifies him.Fan theoryWas Homelander's Apocalyptic Threat in Season 5 Underwhelming?Community discussions on r/TheBoys show a split over how Season 5 handled Homelander as an apocalyptic threat. While several fan posts argue his scale of destruction and presence peaked in Season 1, other viewers point to Antony Starr's performance, brutal individual hits, and the character's broader allegory as highlights.Fan theoryDid Stan Edgar and Vought Really Win at the End of The Boys?Following the end of the show and Homelander's death, fan discussion on r/TheBoys is split over the ultimate fate of Vought and Stan Edgar. While some viewers argue that Edgar came out mostly unscathed with Vought still running, others point out that rebuilding the company amid public condemnation and potential prosecutions will not be easy.